Sergei Sobyanin explained how deceived equity holders will get their apartments. Andrei Vorobyov admitted inability to solve the problem of interest holders Government decree on defrauded equity holders

The regions will draw up “road maps” for solving the problem and will report to the Ministry of Construction on a quarterly basis.

Regional authorities will report to the Ministry of Construction on how to solve the problem of defrauded equity holders. The corresponding order was signed by Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev. Governors will have to submit reports on a quarterly basis, and an indicator of the ratio of the number of share agreements in the problematic objects to the total number of contracts will be taken into account when assessing the effectiveness of regional authorities. In turn, the Ministry of Construction once a quarter will send reports to the government, said department head Mikhail Men.

The obligation of the authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation to report on the solution of the problem of defrauded equity holders is fixed in the order of the government No. 1063-r, which Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev signed on May 26. According to the document, the regions should draw up plans (“road maps”) of work in this direction according to the approved form by August 1. The plan should include a list of problematic objects, the number of deceived equity holders, and a list of unscrupulous companies. Also, local authorities will need to indicate what legislative, organizational and financial measures they plan to take, and what results are expected from this. Deputy governors are appointed responsible for the implementation of the roadmaps.

According to the decree, progress reports and updated plans should be sent to the Ministry of Construction on a quarterly basis. The department has the responsibility to monitor the implementation of the "road maps" and report to the government on how the regions facilitate the situation of equity holders.

By working with problem objects, they will evaluate the professionalism of regional authorities. According to the Minister of Construction and Housing and Communal Services of the Russian Federation, Mikhail Men, to Izvestia at the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, the ratio of the number of share agreements in distressed facilities to the total number of contracts was included in the list of indicators by which processes in the real sector of the economy are monitored, financial, banking and social spheres of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. According to it, in the future, the effectiveness of the executive bodies of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation will be evaluated.

It is important for the regional authorities to tighten control over the terms of construction of houses that are being erected with the involvement of citizens' funds, as well as the implementation of measures aimed at restoring the rights of defrauded real estate investors, ”said Mikhail Men.

According to the Ministry of Construction, the number of DDUs in problem homes of the total number of such agreements concluded by citizens on average in the country is 5.43%. In some regions, it exceeds 20%, and in some regions, on the contrary, below the average.

The president of the Moscow Region Developers Association, Andrey Puchkov, believes that the participation of the authorities of the subjects in solving the problem can significantly improve the situation of defrauded real estate investors nationwide.

Our experience with the government of the Moscow Region confirms that if the region is actively involved in the fate of deceived equity holders, then the problem is solved. In the Moscow region, efforts began to be actively made, and out of 20 thousand cheated, 5.5 thousand remained. A lot depends on the position of the local authorities, if this approach is applied throughout the country, then, of course, the reliability of the market will increase, ”said Andrey Puchkov.

Alexander Sidyakin, head of the working group of the presidium of the United Russia General Council on protecting the rights of equity holders, said that now there are about 900 distressed shared construction projects in the country. He called the idea of \u200b\u200bmonitoring correct and noted that its introduction will allow "to understand where the government worked out everything that it should."

Alexander Sidyakin noted that in a number of regions governors cannot offer a solution to the problem of defrauded equity holders in a number of facilities due to the lack of the necessary amount of funds in regional budgets.

From January 1, 2017, a compensation construction fund for shared construction was created in Russia. The fund was created "in order to compensate citizens for losses and complete the construction of facilities in case of failure by developers to fulfill their obligations under the contract for participation in shared construction."

Regional authorities will quarterly report to the Ministry of Construction on how they solve the problem of defrauded equity holders. The ratio of the number of share agreements in problematic facilities to the total number of DDUs will be taken into account when assessing the effectiveness of regional authorities. In turn, the Ministry of Construction will report to the government on a quarterly basis, said department head Mikhail Men during the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum.

The obligation of the authorities of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation to report on the solution of the problem of defrauded equity holders is fixed in the order of the government No. 1063-r, which Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev signed on May 26. According to the document, the regions should draw up plans (“road maps”) of work in this direction according to the approved form by August 1. The plan should include lists of problematic facilities and dishonest companies, statistics on defrauded equity holders, and legislative, organizational, and financial measures that regional authorities plan to take to solve the problem. Deputy governors are appointed responsible for the implementation of the roadmaps.

According to the decree, progress reports and updated plans should be sent to the Ministry of Construction on a quarterly basis. The department has the responsibility to monitor the implementation of the "road maps" and report to the government on how the regions facilitate the situation of equity holders. “It is important for the regional authorities to tighten control over the timelines for building houses that are being erected with the involvement of citizens, as well as the implementation of measures aimed at restoring the rights of defrauded real estate investors,” the press service of the Ministry of Construction quotes Mikhail Me.

According to the ministry, the number of child care in problem homes of the total number of such agreements concluded by citizens on average in the country is 5.43%. In some regions, it exceeds 20%, and in some regions, on the contrary, below the average.

The president of the Moscow Region Developers Association, Andrey Puchkov, believes that the participation of the authorities of the subjects in solving the problem can significantly improve the situation of defrauded real estate investors nationwide. “Our experience with the government of the Moscow region confirms that if the region is actively involved in the fate of deceived equity holders, then the problem is being solved. In the Moscow region, efforts began to be actively made, and out of 20 thousand cheated, 5.5 thousand remained. A lot depends on the position of local authorities, if this approach is applied throughout the country, then, of course, the reliability of the market will increase, ”Andrei Puchkov quotes newspaper

On January 26, a round table was held in the State Duma on the topic: "The problem of defrauded equity holders: measures to restore the rule of law, the progress in fulfilling the instructions of the President of the Russian Federation." The event was attended by coordinators of the Public Movement of Russian Co-investors from 27 regions of the country. The meeting was organized by the Communist Party faction in the State Duma, and its moderator was State Duma deputy Valery Rashkin.

The personal answer to the citizens was kept by the governor of the Kirov region Igor Vasiliev, deputy governors of the Vologda and Chelyabinsk regions Vitaly Tushinov and Sergey Shal, heads of control divisions, including state construction supervision. A number of regional leaders, such as Volgograd, Leningrad, Saratov, Tomsk, Lipetsk, Yaroslavl, Penza and Amur regions, Perm and Krasnoyarsk Territories, defiantly ignored communication with their real estate investors. However, at the same time, in these regions, the authorities showed that they had “received a signal” by quickly organizing “local” public hearings and meetings of working groups with the participation of deceived citizens.

Comfortable armchairs at the round table were taken by representatives of AHML, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Investigative Committee, the Federal Service for Financial Monitoring, the Ministry of Economic Development, Rosreestr, the Federal Bailiff Service and the Federal Property Management Agency. True, many of them preferred to remain silent and began to speak only after the moderator of the meeting Valery Rashkin “forced” them into a dialogue. After the presentation of each of the regional coordinators, officials spoke. It was at these moments, under the transcript, that they gave generous promises to take measures to solve the problem of equity holders in their region or region.

The main requirement of the meeting participants was the adoption of a federal target program to complete the construction of all 935 long-term construction projects of the country by the end of 2019. Sources of its financing can be both budgetary and extrabudgetary. How and at whose expense their question will be “closed” is not so important for affected citizens. The main thing is to find an effective solution.

Local officials spoke out in support of the federal approach proposed by equity holders to solve the problem in the field of shared construction, and thereby became open opponents to the point of view held by Deputy Prime Minister Igor Shuvalov. Recall, on March 31, 2017, at a meeting of the board of the Ministry of Construction of the Russian Federation, the Deputy Prime Minister said that the federal center has no funds to resolve the accumulated problems, and that the regional authorities directly contacting the developers and issuing construction permits should be responsible for the deceived equity holders of past years. “If they allow those who deceive, then something is unclean there,” said Shuvalov.

Speaking at the round table, Deputy Chairman of the Government of the Omsk Region Sergey Frolov frankly stated that “without federal funding, we will not finish building the house. We, the regions, will not raise this money. Let's put three billion in the budget in the second half of the year, and six more next year. And the topic is closed. ”

We must clearly and clearly say: there are 214 federal laws. So make it work. Interest holders suffered only due to the fact that this law does not work. This is already understandable as twice two four. For 14 years, people have been thrown around the country unmeasured. Thank God everyone is alive from those who ruled and adopted this law. Have you adopted the law? Does not work? So, punish the one who adopted and signed this law. Make those amendments that will work, and interest holders will cease to be a bargaining chip in political games. It’s incorrect to say that the region is to blame. The law was adopted at the federal level. And you don’t need to look for a “scapegoat” in the face of the municipality or region, - this position was indicated by the deputy head of the Sochi city administration Ivan Bomberger.

An important issue discussed at the event was the implementation by regional regulatory bodies of schedule schedules (“road maps”), which prescribe the completion mechanism for each of the problematic construction projects. Unfortunately, even for those long-term construction projects for which such “road maps” have been drawn up, their content is often of a formal nature. They, as a rule, do not have clear and transparent decisions, and make schedules just to report to the federal ministry. According to the Public Movement of Co-investors of Russia, 56% of the country's frozen construction projects, in principle, do not have “road maps”, and about a third of the objects have not even received problem status. And if so, then no solutions need to be found on them. 45% of the developed schedules regularly break down the deadlines for the implementation of the activities laid down in them. It has come to anecdotal cases when, for example, officials from Adygea indicate in the schedules as the final result of their work not to get apartments by citizens, but to “remove social tension”. It turns out why this huge army of leaders exists ... They themselves are not interested in human problems.

Interest-holders from the Vologda Oblast Aleksey Timofeev used a good image when talking about schedules, calling the “road map” a sweet pill for an interest-holder and a formal reply for Moscow.

The roadmap can be effectively drawn up so that it works, only if the developer or investor has the intention to complete this object. We now have a large number of criminal cases initiated against developers who have committed crimes. And some construction projects stopped because the developer simply “closed”. In these cases, it is impossible for an investor to enter an object within the framework of the current legislation, ”said Pavel Koshkin, deputy head of the construction supervision department of the administration of the Krasnodar Territory.

Moreover, an official from Krasnodar openly spoke out in favor of using the funds of the compensation fund to solve the problems of current facilities. With this statement, he thwarted the applause of the audience. Pavel Koshkin’s argument was as follows: now the fund’s money has been frozen for at least the next two years, since before this time a problematic situation with new facilities is simply impossible. And people need help now.

There are issues with the provision in several regions of compensatory land plots. Pavel Koshkin noted that the norms of Federal Law 214 contradict the norms of the law on investment activity. This is a serious obstacle. At the same time, many representatives of the regional authorities complained in their speeches that there were no liquidated compensation plots in their territories and regions. AHML often resists giving away tidbits of land. This was paid attention, including, and interest holders of Kaliningrad. The right site is right at the fence of the construction site, but the "golden" land is along the federal highway. The department of the Plutnik does not want to part with it.

None of the long-term construction of the country has a completed construction and financial expertise. Neither the federal, nor even the regional authorities know the exact amount necessary to “close” the problem of deceived equity holders once and for all.

The concept of "preference" for players in the construction market is not transparent. Entering the frozen facilities, sanatorium developers do not know what they will eventually receive and whether the bureaucratic brothers will suddenly change the informal rules of the game.

As it is thought, it is important to determine at the legislative level the principle of forming “road maps” for problematic objects, the mechanism for their control and the procedure for the responsibility of officials. Initiative groups of interest holders should be involved in the preparation of schedules. But the control of execution must be entrusted to the bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the prosecutor's office. When an official understands that he is supervised by a prosecutor and, if something happens, will bring him to justice, the degree of his consciousness will obviously increase.

Evgeni Kurbalov, a co-owner of the New Scandinavia LCD from St. Petersburg, bluntly stated that “roadmaps” exist only for the report of regional authorities to the federal authorities. In the city, the connection between representatives of initiative groups and officials has been lost. It is necessary to develop a mechanism for local managers to report to equity holders.

According to Yulia Petrukhina, coordinator of the Public Movement of Russian Co-investors in the Moscow Region, “today there is some reluctance among law enforcement agencies to disclose criminal schemes. The deadlines for investigating criminal cases are constantly being drawn out. This was confirmed by 47% of representatives of 416 objects surveyed. Interest holders in their statements write about the affiliate campaigns of the builder, about the real beneficiaries, about the withdrawal of funds and deliberate bankruptcy. 60% of long-term construction projects are in bankruptcy. However, the deadlines for crimes in the field of shared construction have been reduced to five years. ”

The injured participant in the construction of the Pskov region, Irina Kirillova, spoke about the widespread in the region scheme of buying housing not from the developer, but from the contractor. In this scheme, the largest developer of the Pskov region LUG Group, which is owned by Yan Luzin, the former head of the Pskov administration, now a deputy of the regional assembly, constantly flashes. His father is an ex-FSB officer. “Suddenly” the businessman terminated the contract with the contractor, and people lost their apartments. Citizens applied at the local level to all authorities, but did not receive support. Only access to the federal level gave a “magic kick” to the regional authorities. With the mediation of Governor Andrei Turchak at that time, a tripartite agreement was concluded between the administration of the Pskov Region, the developer and contractor, which determined the mechanism for breaking the deadlock. However, after Turchak moved to Moscow, all agreements were canceled. The situation is critical. The criminal case is actually frozen. People are afraid to take this problem out of the region.

Paradoxical were the speeches of some representatives of the authorities. So, the governor of the Kirov region, Igor Vasiliev, suddenly started talking about the fact that “interaction with interest holders should be a two-way street” and called on them to dialogue. It is significant that for some reason he did not begin to listen to the performance of interest holders in his area and left the meeting an hour after it began. Here is a "two-way traffic" turned out. It is also curious that Igor Vasiliev appeared in the State Duma immediately after the mass appeals of injured citizens to the regional government with an expression of distrust of the head of the region. Speaking in his speech only of 192 deceived equity holders, the governor for some reason “forgot” that in the Kirov region there were already fifty problems. Only eight are officially recognized as such. However, this is not surprising: the real numbers for the number of affected equity holders and the number of frozen construction sites in each of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation are, as a rule, underestimated from two to 10 times.

We must not wait for mercy. We have the right to demand, not ask. And we also should not praise regional authorities for fulfilling their direct duties, ”said Yana Vashanova, a lender of the LCD“ Raduzhny ”from the Leningrad Region, in her speech.

Deputy Minister of Construction and Housing and Public Utilities of the Russian Federation Nikita Stasishin, who promised to be at the event, “unexpectedly” and “on time” flew to Izhevsk to meet with Presidential Envoy to the Volga Federal District Mikhail Babich. There was no answer to the question whether he could entrust the presence at the round table to his subordinates, for example, the head of the Department of Housing Policy Olga Kornienko. Apparently, direct and honest conversation with interest holders, representing a third of the regions of the country, officials of the relevant ministry simply do not need. Isn’t it time for these people to think about their suitability for their position?

For equity holders, it is obvious that the current leadership of the Ministry of Construction is simply engaged in self-PR, creating raw and incomplete "information systems" and cutting ribbons in front of long-built houses, but not at the same time offering truly effective and ready-made solutions in the field of shared construction. As you know, "fish rots from the head." Maybe it makes sense to propose to the country's leadership a list of candidates for the post of head of the relevant ministry? Obviously, professionals who can solve long-standing social problems in the construction field should enter it.

The head of the working group of the State Duma to solve the problems of the participants in the shared construction of the deputy from United Russia Nikolai Nikolaev also did not have time to talk with almost a hundred leaders of initiative groups of equity holders from all over the country. He sent a “polite refusal” to the organizers, in which he actively praised himself and his achievements. As they say, you will not praise yourself ...

According to the apt remark of Yulia Petrukhina, “the entire state machine is aimed at creating the illusion of work. Instead of discussing the timing of the transfer of keys to deceived equity holders, they report to the President how many road maps have been prepared and how many objects have been mapped. But they don’t report how many objects do not have a problem status, how many deadlines on road maps are broken. ”

The resolution adopted at the end of the round table contains a number of fundamental requirements, including

• determine the financial responsibility of the Russian Federation as a state to participants in shared construction in the form of state financing (co-financing) of sanatorium developers.
• Introduce a workable mechanism for the rehabilitation of construction campaigns, which for one reason or another failed to fulfill their obligations to citizens by analogy with the rehabilitation mechanism widely used in the banking sector.
• As a component of such a scheme, it is proposed to consider the creation of a specialized (private) -state developer, one of the functions of which will be the completion of the construction of problem objects on the market at the expense of budget and extra-budgetary funds.
• Regional executive authorities should ensure the creation of a final list (pool) of developers, sanatoriums, whose participants will commit themselves to complete the problematic facilities in each region of the country.

Igor Assanov,

northwest Focal Point

Social movement of interest holders of Russia

The state has been assisting deceived equity holders for at least the past ten years. And judging by the fact that the robbed people still want what they want, and in the end they get what the legislator offers, and at the same time they continue to hope that the authorities will solve their problems, the government is successfully coping with its task. The country has stability and order.

After 70 years of totalitarianism, Russian citizens, in which their rights were terribly restricted by the Soviet state, finally got freedom and began to live in a rule of law state. And this is actually so. The Russians began to have many different rights, because in a democracy, everyone is free. Everyone is free - both the people and the government, which freely promises everything that the people want and is not responsible for their promises. All this is done for the benefit of the whole people. Although the people for some reason do not like such care. People do not understand that to have everything at once, now only those who can secure their rights without restrictions can afford it.

And in order for the rest to leave the right to fulfill their desires only in the bright future, the main task of the authorities is to create conditions that do not allow to exercise their rights freely here and now, to every willing citizen of the rule of law. An equally important task facing the authorities is the prevention of social tension, which necessarily arises from the violation of the rights of a free person.  This task is unusually difficult, but, as practice shows, is doable. For this, it is necessary to maintain the confidence among the layman that the state tirelessly cares about him. But it does not have time to give everyone everything that they desire by right, so the free citizen has to wait for this. And in order for such a concern to be carried out as soon as possible, it is necessary to reach the authorities by any means proposed by the same state.

In such an illusion, through the efforts of the authorities, the majority of deceived equity holders continues to remain. In reality to however, the federal and regional authorities do not consider deceived investors to be deceived at all.  Indeed, no one will believe that the opinion of officials appointed by the federal center may contradict the opinion of the authorities, and the subordinate will defend his opinion, contrary to the will of the authorities. The state passes laws, and subordinates comply with them, that is, they express the will of the state. For this, the law FZ-214 was invented. And if everything is done according to the law, then according to the state, the interest holder who is left with nothing is not considered to be deceived. This deceived believe otherwise. That is their right. No one forbids having your own opinion. After all, we have a legal state ...

Some of the deceived equity holders manage to escape from the captivity of their own illusions. It is then that we can observe that equity holders put on an equal footing with the rest of the deceived, seek to receive the apartments they promised, without any additional conditions from the developer or the local administration. It cannot be said that something has changed around them, but a certain reappraisal of their own experience has taken place. This is normal for those who have been able to act continuously and long enough to see what these or other actions have led to. For those who have enough courage to impartially look at themselves and their past. This is normal for smart people. If you did everything correctly, reevaluation will be minimal and lost time will not be critical.

There are such examples, but no one thinks why they happen. It is not peculiar to our citizens, as well as not ours, to delve into the details. Well, they got it and got it, it’s lucky, they shouted, finished writing, complained, heard their authorities and felt sorry for the unfortunate. Everything is simple. We are doing the same thing and we should be lucky. Why are we worse? So they continue to walk year after year in the same circle created by puppeteers for them. They continue to walk until they completely disbelieve in everything and finally give up their hands. After all, they created all the conditions for the deceived people to fight as if in a concrete wall.

Until people could overcome their fear -  EVERYTHING'S UNDER CONTROL. The dull and hopeless action, which the deceived for some reason call the struggle for their apartments, continues. It is not surprising that such victims continue to wait for help for decades. They could not understand that their main problem is that they only think that they are doing the same. The real estate investors, who are waiting for help from the authorities, will never understand that there will never be any help, and those who have got their apartments or are only really moving towards this goal have accomplished the most important thing for their victory. They realized that there would be no help from the STATE and stopped waiting for her. To agree to destroy the illusion is always the most difficult. If you could, then further action is a matter of time, not difficulties. They are already committed deliberately, and the difficulties that arise are overcome much more easily.

Deceived equity holders constantly complain that the law 214-FZ does not work. In reality, the law works, but not for them. And they convinced interest holders of the opposite only in order to stimulate potential buyers to take risks and give their money for a promise, and not for real apartments. Indeed, for most fully sane and adult people, it is preferable to have a tit in their hand than a crane in the sky. The government needed to break this conviction that effective managers, judging by what was happening, successfully demonstrated to everyone.

From public experience it is known that the law as a drawbar, wherever you turn, it happened. FZ-214 is a vivid confirmation of this. The law provided for the state the opportunity to evade responsibility by transferring it to the shoulders of the deceived equity holders themselves.  Therefore, the authorities are making every effort to force the robbed and homeless people to accept this. Like you see that we have come up with a law for you, which should protect you, and you are so "fluffy suckers" that even the law did not help you. The state shrugs its hands, it seems like we did everything for the people that we could. What is our demand? You were robbed in full accordance with the law.

Therefore, the authorities provided three options for equity holders. These options are arranged by deceived equity holders or not, the state does not care. The task of the authorities, "by not washing in such a way," to make the indignant proposed by the failed newcomer, agree with one of the proposed options. The most worthy, because it is beneficial for local officials - this is the first way to solve the problem out of such an unpleasant choice for equity holders.

In this case, officials insist on this method of solving the problem in most cases. This option implies a lot of nishtyak for "those who share." As a result, there is an increase in problems for those who pay - deceived equity holders who have become voluntary shareholders. But this is the topic of a separate article, so here we will not dwell on it in detail.

We mean HBC the abbreviation which the people called in their own way, capaciously and precisely: “Live As You Can”.

1 .Creation of housing cooperative (housing construction cooperative).   Citizens themselves must form it, and only the bankruptcy manager of a developer-bankrupt can initiate this. In the future, equity holders who became shareholders of this cooperative, according to the state, should act as an investor in financing the further completion of the object.
2. Sale of the subject of pledge.  It is applicable only if the property is encumbered. But in this case, 60% of the proceeds will go to repay the claims of creditors on the obligation secured by collateral. And only 25% of the funds - to repay the requirements of interest holders. True, the same 25% is ideal.
3 .Transfer of property and developer obligations. This norm, according to many experts, today is idle, "dead" due to the lack of economic feasibility. Attracting another investor for completion is beneficial only when it can be profitable. But most of the apartments in problem homes are usually sold out, and the construction costs remain for the new company. In a falling market, even such a theoretical possibility can only be regarded as fiction. Therefore, even if the so-called "investor" appears, then he most often uses the site in his commercial interests, then safely bankrupts the company. There is also a second option, when the site is being completed under a new nameand deceived equity holders are left with nothing.

As planned by the authorities, the deceived shareholder must meekly agree with one of the options proposed by the legislator and forget about any claims to the state. Moreover, the state and those gentlemen whose interests the government protects have already received everything from the shareholder. And the fact that he was left with nothing was his problem. Not to return to him, in fact, what was deceived from him. Let, in general, rejoice that they have not finally let go of the world. Let him sit on his priest exactly, in the kitchen of a rented apartment and let off “steam” in social networks. Let him hope for a bright future, which state representatives regularly promise. Let the letters be written, in the end, for this there are regulatory bodies that distract citizens from unnecessary activity. Let him walk in a circle and get unsubscribing until he gets tired and disappointed in everything. There are deputies, there is an administration, a court in the end. Let him leave the race, freeing up space for running through bureaucratic offices, new deceived. Let anyone survive as best they can. For those with a better life, the state will come up with something else. For the calm of the state, the main thing is that the deceived shareholder does not take to the streets with the demand for justice.

  Of course, deceived equity holders have rights, but the state does not give them the opportunity to exercise these rights. Or do we not live in a state of law? In fact. In a democracy, the main principle of existence is the privatization of revenues and the nationalization of expenses. Therefore, our people are protected by law and, only very few, are not protected ...   And they, that is, the state, have new tasks and new “suckers fluffy” ahead. Those who still have something to lure. THE PROBLEM FOR THE STATE IS ONLY INCLUDEDthat the deceived ones don’t think and don’t want to (don’t be grateful, how much they promised, how much they were told and told, wait and ... wait, the wizard will appear on the “blue helicopter” and provide you with a bright future ...). Nevertheless, the disadvantaged do not want to agree with the opinion of the authorities, and their number is constantly growing, as is social tension.

But the state does not despair and works hard with the dull population. The number of all kinds of all-Russian congresses held by various political interests is growing. B most interest holders still continue to turn to officials for help, asking for attention, writing complaints, signing petitions, and waiting for representatives of the authorities at rallies. In general, they are doing everything so that the authorities are confident that everything is under the state’s control. Therefore, to twitch and worry, and even more so to solve the problem as requested and wanted by the deceived, there is no reason.

Of course, there are those whose problem will have to be solved, but their quality has not yet grown into a disturbing state. Life, as you know, is far from ideal, but power has both strength and desire and the ability to become closer to the ideal. In a rule of law state, stability is only preserved when it acts, and does not expect a bright future, like most of its citizens. Perhaps that is why the unprotected sections of the population already have everything in the present. Unlike most deceived equity holders, the realization of the rights of which is promised by the state, only in the bright future.

Author: Sergey Popov, Maxim Rodionov, Vladimir Smirnov, specially for “Strength in Motion”

Governor Andrei VOROBYEV asked for help from the federal authorities to solve the problems of defrauded real estate investors in the Moscow Region.

During a visit to the Moscow Region by the Plenipotentiary Envoy of the President of Russia in the Central Federal District Alexey GORDEEVA  the governor said that the regional authorities will not be able to independently help the remaining five thousand equity holders.

In his speech, Vorobyov lamented that because "Bureaucratic delays"  the solution to the interest-holders problem is being delayed, even despite the demand of Vladimir Putin to deal with the long-term construction projects as quickly as possible: “ contrary to the instructions, the ministries and departments are in no hurry with the necessary approvals and do not contribute to the solution of the problems of equity holders ”:

In the Moscow region there were a lot of deceived equity holders, we solved the problems of 20 thousand. Five thousand remained, and here we are unable to satisfy the rights of citizens without federal support and a federal solution.

Today there were representatives of interest holders, the Lukino quarter in particular. A number of objects require compensatory development, in particular, "High Larks" in Odintsovo.

Housing estate “High Larks”, September 2017

However, Andrei Vorobyov did not specify the reasons why the federal ministries and departments are in no hurry with approvals and do not contribute to resolving the problems of equity holders. Is it not a matter of the fact that departments reveal violations during the construction of facilities and the preparation of documentation at the regional level, after which they refuse to coordinate?

The regional authorities did everything to aggravate the situation

Also in his speech, Andrey Vorobyov called the situation with interest holders "Heavy inheritance", which the regional authorities are trying to eliminate, but lack authority. But here it is worth noting that one of the main culprits of the current situation is the Moscow Region Ministry of the Construction Complex, which has been issuing and extending all building permits since 2014.

Problems with interest-holders are largely created by the authorities of the region, which is now requesting help from the federals to fulfill the instructions of Vladimir Putin. And complains about the lack of authority. It turns out that the disease hit the region so deeply that even emergency shock therapy in the form of providing land without bidding no longer helps.

How much more taxpayer funds will be spent on the treatment of a chronic patient?

But the main thing is not “bureaucratic delays” and interaction with the ministries, which Andrei Vorobyov speaks about, but how much it costs to save interest-holders for taxpayers.

According to experts, only last summer, the delivery of keys 12 thousand  interest holders cost the regional budget in . - near 4 million rubles  for everyone! Based on this, it can be assumed that the remaining 5 thousand injured  Vorobyov will spend more 20 billion